[17:32] ~~~The Log Starteth Here~~~ [17:32] (Bill, Michelle, you're both logging right?) [17:32] yu[ [17:32] p [17:32] (yup) [17:32] Before we start to judge, I am giving time for complaints about the quality of the finalists to be made [17:32] ~~~The Tupos Starteth Here~~~ [17:32] * TheAmnesiacOne *complains about the finalists* [17:33] I personally would like to complain about the quality of the Trek punchlines, particularly the fact that there are *four* using the demotion joke [17:33] good point [17:33] and none of them are mine.... Heh [17:33] I have been asked by Wizzard to repeat his thoughts, namely "did you see a funny line in the finalists btw?" [17:33] yes - and the "ensign" joke is becoming a little overused... [17:34] I would like to say that I think 6 punchlines ism [17:34] oh right, judging. :P [17:34] isn't enough for TT [17:34] And again from Wizzard, that he would cut all of the demotion punchlines [17:34] And it was he who alerted me to the fact that one TT and one Trek each come from their respective top tens [17:35] but... shouldn't the top tens be an indication of the funniest lines? [17:35] Not the ones I've been reading. [17:35] maybe he meant that *only* one each comes from there? [17:35] Iris - I agree that we could use a couple more on TT [17:35] and shouldn't more punchlines therefore be chosen from their respective top tens...? [17:35] That's what I said isn't it? It's what I meant, I didn't say it very well [17:35] sorry :S [17:36] (Couldn't quote him because he got it wrong at first :0P ) [17:36] Michelle - not you, what Iris said [17:37] Everyone got all the complaints on record that they would like to make? [17:37] **DING!** ~~~~Starteth Again...~~~ [17:37] I guess so [17:37] (That's going in the log btw, 'swhy I made it clear when I wanted the log to start ;0) [17:38] well, it was worth a try, but I'm tired, & off to bed now [17:38] goodnight all [17:38] *** Laitainion has quit IRC (Quit: ) [17:38] Stop Hi.... bugger. [17:38] mrr... [17:39] (Sorry for the slight delay, realised I need to check something quickly) [17:39] (okies) [17:39] If you did it quickly, why was there a delay? [17:40] complaints....hmmm....no....think everything's already said......or well....can't think of anything new to nag about right now....(well, I could, but that's got nothing to do with the JS and stuff. :-P) [17:40] Bah, nevermind (was trying to find out how to format text in Chatzilla, will just have to pay attention) [17:40] *** EofS is now known as EofSev [17:40] * EofSev asks your opinion of GUESS [17:40] I GUESS we ran out of ensigns... [17:40] Cut [17:40] cut [17:40] cut [17:40] cut [17:40] cut [17:41] CUT 100% [17:41] * EofSev asks your opinion of LUCKY [17:41] cut [17:41] cut [17:41] A lieutenant is just a LUCKY ensign [17:41] cut [17:41] Keep [17:41] neutral [17:41] (if those still count?) [17:41] CUT 20-20-60% [17:42] I'd rather no neutrals (otherwise I would have neutralled that one, it's not that I *liked* it) [17:42] * EofSev asks your opinion of PULLING [17:42] Not enought judges for frills. [17:42] PULLING rank is futile [17:42] keep [17:42] keep [17:42] Keep [17:42] okay....so only yes and no's, no maybes... :P [17:42] keep [17:42] (mmmmmhm ;)) [17:42] cut [17:42] 5 is a good number for working out percentages though ;0) [17:42] heh, that it is ;) [17:42] KEEP 80-20% [17:43] * EofSev asks your opinion of SHIELD [17:43] (10 would be better though (hint hint) ;) ) [17:43] *** Dhraakellian has quit IRC (Ping timeout) [17:43] We had to demote you for "human SHIELD" purposes [17:43] (If only...) [17:43] cut [17:43] cut [17:43] Cut [17:43] cut [17:43] keep [17:43] narf [17:43] (I wouldn't be doing percentages with more :0P With 4 I would ;0) [17:43] Lazy sevman *nods* [17:43] CUT 20-80% [17:43] FOUR [17:44] *g* [17:44] * EofSev asks your opinion of PROMOTING [17:44] *drool* [17:44] Pinchard to Measly... I'm PROMOTING you to Lieutenant [17:44] cut [17:44] keep [17:44] cut [17:44] keep [17:44] Keep (would be neutral) [17:44] (as would mine) [17:44] This one makes no sense....trying to get measly added to the strip..... [17:44] KEEP 60-40 [17:45] * EofSev asks your opinion of SNAP [17:45] Good thinking on that "SNAP demotion" Mr Barf! [17:45] Keep [17:45] cut [17:45] cut [17:45] keep [17:45] cut [17:45] CUT 40-60% [17:45] * EofSev asks your opinion of SICK [17:46] The judges of SICK of crap punchlines [17:46] Erm, oops [17:46] LOL [17:46] lol! [17:46] I sense the "demotion" punches have been...well...demoted. [17:46] *grin* [17:46] The bored are SICK of assimilating ensigns! [17:46] ack, wrong window was selected, firefox started searching for a link named "finalist culled" when I typed "cu". [17:46] keep [17:46] cut [17:46] *Smiles angelically* [17:46] cut [17:46] (hehe Emma) [17:46] Cut [17:47] cut [17:47] CUT 20-80% [17:47] * EofSev asks your opinion of ADAPTED [17:47] They've ADAPTED [17:47] cut [17:47] keep [17:47] cut [17:47] keep [17:47] Cut [17:47] CUT 40-60% [17:48] * EofSev asks your opinion of DEMOTION (her personal opinion is that it is a rehashed, overused joke that isn't funny and certainly doesn't deserve 4 versions in the finalists) [17:48] Then you didn't hear about your DEMOTION, Ensign... [17:48] cut [17:48] But does deserve plenty of editorial.... [17:48] cut [17:48] cut [17:49] cut [17:49] Cut [17:49] CUT 100% [17:49] (although...*cough*....maybe not try to influence by saying there were FOUR versions culled. ;-)) [17:49] * EofSev asks your opinion of CASE [17:49] In that CASE, you're demoted! [17:49] Cut [17:49] cut [17:49] keep [17:49] cut [17:49] gotta keep one.... [17:50] * TheAmnesiacOne shudders when someone does another emergency break outside [17:50] cut [17:50] eep :S [17:50] CUT 20-80% [17:50] * EofSev asks your opinion of CASE [17:50] Erm, just did that one didn't we [17:50] yes :-P [17:50] FINAL MODE [17:50] well, if you want to rehash that line...*runs* [17:50] but I understand... they all seem the same ;-) [17:50] Bad Leander ;) [17:51] * EofSev asks you to vote4 PULLING or PROMOTING [17:51] :-P [17:51] vote4 pulling [17:51] vote4 pulling [17:51] Vote4 pulling [17:51] vote4 promoting [17:51] vote4 pulling [17:51] (Or if you'd like, a non finalist. But I don't think this is a good week to do taht) [17:51] ehm, no, probably not ;) [17:51] PULLING has 4, PROMOTING has 1 [17:51] PULLING is the winner! [17:51] (I think for that to happen, I'd need more time) [17:52] * Whitestar8472 offers pick 'n' mix sweets (or candy ;)) [17:52] Leander - I was gonna tell people before the session, but it was 5 to 11 before I noticed ;0) [17:52] I'll have the candy... [17:52] yay [17:52] oh question....when JC is selecting the finalist *before* he culls (sp?) them.....do we think there are still enough lines in there that we find funny....on average I mean? [17:53] I don't usually get to see the shortlist... [17:53] sometimes [17:53] I can usually find a number of funny lines pre cull, but stupidly didn't read them this week [17:53] Should remind myself to look at the pre-culled lines more often [17:53] * TheAmnesiacOne goes nuts. [17:53] TT is prepped when you're ready btw [17:53] Iris: meep? [17:53] That car alarm that kept going for half the afternoon just went off again... [17:54] ugh [17:54] *headdesk* [17:54] * Corsair ***thinks back to how long this subject has been discussed in SEV*** [17:54] *Thinks how long too little has been done to combat it* [17:54] (am ready to judge when everyone else is :)) [17:54] well, just that, if we want to do mutiny on lines, it's easier to maybe use the pre-culled lines as a basis? otherwise you have to go through a million lines each time.....because the top 10 lines is an average and could mean that I would like those.....oh...meh, too much text, forgot what I typed at first....*stops tupoing* [17:55] Well I can't attend next week, and the week after I might be tired (gotta get up 4am that day) so might not make it, depends how Nemi and David feel I guess [17:55] But I will try and remember to print out pre-culled finalists for teh next time I do make it [17:55] ouch! [17:56] (oh right, need to kill msn sound...*sigh*....:-P) [17:56] Shall we TT? [17:56] sure [17:56] k [17:56] I suppose for fairness I should give people time to complain about TT punchlines here ;0) [17:56] there aren't enough of them? ;);) [17:56] I wanted "I love being small" because it rhymed! ;-) [17:57] a couple more would do just nicely ;) [17:57] Though I personally don't have much complaint, they're not spectacular, but kinda funny. And yeah, could use a couple more [17:58] (I don't have Wizzard's express opinion, but I don't believe he liked them, so I guess I should say that for him too) [17:58] To quote "feel free to quote my complains about lame and rehashed finalists" [17:58] All done? [17:59] I am [17:59] squeaka squeaka squeaka [17:59] Let's judge! [17:59] *bounce* [17:59] ;-) [17:59] *raises finger* ahhh, no. I'm done. [17:59] * TheAmnesiacOne considers throwing a couple of rocks at a certain car... [17:59] mrrr [17:59] I'll bet that would set the alarm off :0P [17:59] flintstones comes to mind all of a sudden [17:59] but wouldn't that set ...what Emma said ;) [17:59] * EofSev asks your opinion of SCORE [18:00] SCORE one for the Little Guys... [18:00] Cut (leaning to neutral) [18:00] cut [18:00] keep [18:00] keep [18:00] keep [18:00] KEEP 60-40 [18:00] * EofSev asks your opinion of HEIGHT [18:00] Her HEIGHT went to her head. [18:00] Keep [18:00] cut [18:00] cut [18:00] keep (would be neutral) [18:01] cut [18:01] CUT 40-60 [18:01] (sorry, messing with media player) [18:01] * EofSev asks your opinion of WORKS [18:01] WORKS for me too. [18:01] keep [18:01] Keep (to neutral) [18:01] cut [18:01] keep [18:01] keep [18:02] KEEP 80-20 [18:02] * EofSev asks your opinion of POETIC [18:02] And I love POETIC justice [18:02] keep [18:02] keep [18:02] keep (leaning towards neutral) [18:02] Keep (neutral) [18:02] cut [18:02] KEEP 80-20 [18:03] * EofSev asks your opinion of ATTITUDE [18:03] It's about ATTITUDE not altitude [18:03] Keep [18:03] cut (emphatically chosen) [18:03] Keep (neutral) [18:03] keep [18:03] cut [18:03] KEEP 60-40 [18:03] * EofSev asks your opinion of BAD [18:03] Being short ain't so BAD either Sister! [18:03] Cut [18:03] cut (definitely cut!) [18:03] cut (curiously unfettered) [18:04] cut [18:04] cut [18:04] CUT 100% [18:04] * EofSev asks your to vote between SCORE, WORKS, POETIC and ATTITUDE [18:04] Vote4 WORKS [18:05] vote4 works [18:05] vote4 works [18:05] vote4 attitude [18:05] vote4 score... errr, no works... ahhhhh....poetic... **oh sure, NOW you can't decide...**** [18:05] (I was going to go for attitude, but after voting to keep it suddenly realised that I don't like it :0P ) [18:05] vote4 score Yes, that's it. [18:05] WORKS has 3, ATTITUDE has 1, SCORE has 1 [18:05] Any complaints against WORKS winning? [18:06] ohhh, ok. Works then. [18:06] not here [18:06] Well you did vote for it ;0) [18:06] yes, didn't vote for that one. :-P [18:06] WORKS wins! [18:06] hehe ;) [18:06] nah, it's okay [18:06] Leander - I wondered if one of you would say that ;0) [18:06] Any comments for the log? [18:06] hehe [18:07] http://forum.sevspace.com/discussionboard/db_messages/13678.asp [18:07] we need more judges? *makes puppy dog eyes* [18:07] Since it's about to fall off the board, a link for posterity [18:07] yes....to anyone who reads this log on and wants to visit a JS......you're free to do so! [18:07] So That's where those come from... [18:07] :P [18:07] ~~~The Log Endeth Here~~~ [18:07] *** EofSev is now known as EofS